American Idol contestant Alyssa Raghu sang Sara Bareilles’ “She Used to Be Mine” from the Broadway musical Waitress during the April 14.

The 17-year-old performed the emotional ballad as part of Top 14 week on the reality singing competition; the Top 10 will be revealed April 15 on ABC.

Waitress opened on Broadway in 2016 and was nominated for four Tony Awards including Best Musical and Best Original Score for Bareilles. Shoshana Bean currently takes on the role of Jenna at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre, joined by Tony nominee Jeremy Jordan.